17: How to choose between a Source & Meter, LTS, or Two-Way Instrument

Written by Bruce Robertson, 03. Reviewed Dec 2005. © Kingfisher International

Source & Meter

Advantages compared to LTS:

More flexibility. One source & meter can measure a link, whereas two LTS (Loss Test Set) instruments are needed.
A source is not needed to do transmission power measurements, so it can be used elsewhere.
The KI7600 series power meter has a built in visible fault locator option.
A single source instrument can have both multimode and singlemode emitters.
The source and meter should be matched so that "Autotest" works.

Disadvantages compared to LTS:

Higher initial cost. One LTS may be cheaper than a source / meter pair.
More inventory to maintain and deploy, so higher ongoing costs.
Higher battery cost.
Slightly harder to use.

Loss Test Set

Advantages compared to source and meter:

Maybe lower initial cost.
Less inventory to maintain and deploy, so lower ongoing costs.
Lower battery cost.
Slightly simpler to use.

Disadvantages compared to source and meter:

Generally can't verify a link with just one unit, at least two are required.
Source (cost) must be carried during power measurements, when it's not required.

Two Way Instrument

Advantages compared to LTS:

Much easier & faster two way (bi-directional) loss checking with minimum skill level.
Pass / Fail display.
Option of ORL measurement for small extra cost and no extra effort.

Disadvantages compared to LTS:

Initial Cost.

When considering these options, remember that the Total Cost Of Ownership is usually dominated by labour, calibration, training, inventory management and other indirect costs.

More Information

You may print, photocopy and redistribute this document for educational use only, provided that this page is printed as is, without modification. This page may not be used commerically.